WE WANTED TO MANUFACTURE IN AMERICA, BUT CHINA WON


“Every project, every product is different.”
— George Stroumboulis

ARTICLE SUMMARY

I explain why our early manufacturing decisions led us to China after considering other locations. Custom decorative lighting required different products and molds for different projects, so we had to weigh the costs and production processes against the kind of business we were building.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Our manufacturing evaluation considered the requirements of custom projects rather than a fixed product range.

  • Tooling costs and control of production processes were important parts of that decision.

WE TALK ABOUT MANUFACTURING IN CHINA ON A RECENT PODCAST EPISODE

George Stroumboulis: And we're no different. So to that point, when we launched this company, right? Custom decorative lighting was the genesis, the basis. And we explored, hey, what if we manufactured here in California? What if we look south of the United States and some of the Latin countries? And we weighed out what does it cost? And what we decided in the end, it’s very difficult because we don't offer a portfolio of a few products that don't change and we stock them and so on. Every project, every product is different. And when we started evaluating on the basic cost on creating molds. Every product is a different mold. Well, doing it over in China and creating that mold versus here, and we're talking 3, 4, 5x in many cases and a single product may have multiple molds. And we started looking at that and we realized, hey, we’re not a commodity driven manufacturing company. It didn't make sense up until recently to start looking over here. So that was why we were over there. And a lot of the times, anyone can go on their computer or their phone and check Alibaba and find any type of product. So a lot of the times you see now people think that they're experts in buying and procurement and, oh, I can get this lighting fixture. Yeah. There's a lot of crap out there. There's decent product as well you can buy. But what we did is, we manufactured in China, the majority of our products, but we own, the factory that we're manufacturing in, right? So we have our hub, we control the labor, we control the processes, what comes in and out. And we have this elaborate network of subcontractors from the different suppliers and the LEDs, like you said, some of them are being imported from Japan or South Korea. So we've created this hub where we truly control the process. It just happens right now. The economies of scale, the economics of manufacturing our products and what we're able to sell it to our clients makes sense for us to continue to produce there. And it’s been this crossing of paths right now on, yet we understand we have to manufacture there to do this, but we also know there's tremendous pressure from our clients here in the United States, North America on made in America, bring manufacturing back home. And it's a very technical balancing act in trying to make sure and just really quick on that, years ago at the last startup, I was in a client meeting and it was a big retail brand. And I remember sitting in the meeting and there was someone who was sitting across the table and just certain people you sit with and you know, they just don't want to do business because they have their partners. And, I remember we're talking and we're talking about why we're so good in our products and everything. And I remember this gentleman across the table is like, well, you just make this in China. And he said it in such an aggressive way. And I'm like, we sure do. Yep. We manufacture in China. I go, where is your clothing manufactured? And he just kind of stood back and like looked at it. I go, I'm just curious. Like where do you manufacture your clothing, he’s like, China. I go, right, but you're still selling a good quality product the same way we make a good quality product. And it was just one of those things right now and it's got this stigma made in China and now politically it's escalated it. So talk to me about our next step, even though we manufacture in China, we've started in our New York facility, actually assembling and getting more creative in that aspect.

Chris Hartswick: Yeah. I mean, like you said, when we're focused on the decorative side, it's so difficult to be able to do a full manufacturing on our business model anywhere really, but especially here in the US. Because we have so many different materials that we use, we have so many different molding techniques that we use. We have so many different assembly techniques and installation and all of that requires such specialty equipment, knowledge on how to use the equipment, specialty engineering. And it's also important to note that when we went to China and being established in China, it wasn't, to your point before, we didn't just Google custom lighting China on Alibaba and go to the first three places. We went through…

George Stroumboulis: Which, by the way, a lot of people do and think that's what we're competing with. It's like great.

Chris Hartswick: Right. And even if they don't do that, most people think that's all you need to do. But, I mean, how many, I couldn't even answer the question. If we went through how many different suppliers we worked with and fired and got rid of and changed and moved because of, they weren't, whatever it was, the quality wasn't there. The negotiation wasn't there. The communication wasn't there. They were falling behind on lead times, whatever that is to get established anywhere, not just in China, is not something you can do overnight. Especially when you have a business model like we do. And every product requires a whole different level of skill. So to go back to your question, what are we doing here? Well, one, we've been starting to expand elsewhere in general, right? We've been looking in India specifically, been looking in parts of Eastern Europe, and parts of Mexico. So that involves not just having great suppliers, but also having a great team. In China, we have our engineering team.

Chris Hartswick: We have our own employees, our engineering team, our quality control guys. We have an entire team that, when we're manufacturing something at a molder, our, at least two engineers are sitting there at the mold. They're watching production get made, they're doing IQL of the products before it even comes off the line, before it even ships to our facility to assemble. You have to have that level of oversight and that level of control to make sure that you're not going to have problems later on even down the road warranty issues. So that's what we've already started doing, growing our European office using that as our central hub to get into India and Eastern Europe. We've been hiring in Eastern Europe, getting more engineers in there, so they can speak that local language and talk with those local suppliers.

George Stroumboulis: Yeah. Two weeks we're going to be over in southeast Europe surveying a possible partnership with some local suppliers there, these component suppliers.

Chris Hartswick: So it's not something that happens overnight. You got to build those cornerstones and building blocks to make sure that it all comes together. But it's something that we actively are working on and have been so that we can manufacture more and more. And when it comes to our more standard type products, our cylinders, our [Inaudible 14:33 – 14:34]. We do so much final assembly here. Molds come from all over the place, wherever that is. Electronics come from all over the place. But the final assembly of that we are able to do here.

George Stroumboulis: And by the way, just the way we engineer our products to be able to snap into place, different color temperatures, different beams, just being able to do that here and bring everything, 3D printing is the next wave of where we're going, which I want you to jump into by the whole 3D printing, additive manufacturing, which is becoming like the big term buzzword. You’re going to be speaking later this summer at an event down here in Southern California. So talk to us about the importance, like what were we hindered by before by being able to use 3D printing and develop different components with lighting from optic constraints from thermal management and where are we going right now? Because it's totally revolutionized the direction of this.

George Stroumboulis and Chris Hartswick recording a manufacturing discussion at Ideoli Group in Newport Beach.

George Stroumboulis and Chris Hartswick discuss manufacturing in an internal podcast episode at Ideoli’s Newport Beach offices.



WHAT CUSTOM LIGHTING ASKS OF A MANUFACTURING TEAM

As Chris and I explain in the conversation, our work involves changing materials, molds, assembly methods and installation requirements from project to project. That is why our manufacturing decision had to account for tooling, specialist skills and control of the production process.

The practical questions for a custom lighting project include how the product will be made, who will review it during production, how the team will communicate changes and whether the production plan supports the required delivery date. These are the operating details behind the finished fixture.

The interview records our decisions and plans at that point in the company’s development. Explore my international lighting and manufacturing work and the related discussion of building quality into our factory processes.



OTHER BLOGS